|
Hamas not to blame for current crisis despite Bush claims
Irish Sun Saturday 3rd January, 2009
President Bush has used his weekly radio address to blame Hamas for the Israeli bombardment of Gaza this week.
On Saturday Mr. Bush said, "This recent outburst of violence was instigated by Hamas."
In rather strong language the president said Hamas took over the Gaza Strip 18 months ago "in a coup."
"Egypt brokered a ceasefire between Hamas and Israel, but Hamas routinely violated that ceasefire by launching rockets into Israel," Mr Bush said.
"On December 19th, Hamas announced an end to the ceasefire and soon unleashed a barrage of rockets and mortars that deliberately targeted innocent Israelis, an act of terror that is opposed by the legitimate leader of the Palestinian people, President Abbas," President Bush added.
What was largely being said on Saturday was what Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice said last Saturday when the aerial bombardment of Gaza began.
"We strongly condemn the repeated rocket and mortar attacks against Israel and hold Hamas responsible for breaking the ceasefire and for the renewal of violence there," Rice said. "The ceasefire must be restored immediately and fully respected."
The reality is the ceasefire was being respected by Hamas and was ended by it because Israel, according to Hamas, was not meeting its obligations under the agreement.
President Bush's statement Saturday that Hamas "routinely violated" the ceasefire is at complete odds with the State Department's understanding. Ms Rice herself, in remarks reported by The Associated Press on December 19, the day Hamas announced it would not renew the ceasefire, accepted the ceasefire had largely been observed, and in fact was concerned hostilities would be resumed.
“I sincerely hope that there will not be a resumption of the violence because that is not going to help the people of Gaza, it is not going to help the Palestinians, it is not going to help the Palestinian cause,” she said.
Hamas had been concerned about what it termed Israeli violations. In a statement posted on its Web site on December 19, Hamas said Israel had breached agreements by imposing a painful economic blockade on Gaza, staging military strikes into the densely populated coastal strip and continuing to hunt down Hamas operatives in the West Bank.
“Since the enemy did not abide with the conditions, we hold the enemy fully responsible for ending the truce and we confirm that the Palestinian resistance factions headed by Hamas will act,” the statement said.
What has been overlooked by President Bush and Secretary of State Rice is the incursion by Israel into Gaza on November 5 which left several militants dead. This incident is widely regarded as the main cause of the breakdown in the ceasefire, with both sides, until then, seemingly prepared to live with minor violations.
The Associated Press in an article published on December 19 validated this view.
"Though violence and casualties dropped significantly under the ceasefire agreement, the truce has increasingly unraveled since early November, when Israeli soldiers entered Gaza to destroy a tunnel that the army said could have been used in a cross-border raid. In response, Palestinian militants resumed firing rockets at Israel," The Associated Press reported.
Time magazine in a report published four days earlier on December 15 backed The Associated Press report, and calculated the ceasefire, until the Israeli military raid, had resulted in a dramatic decline in projectile attacks.
"From the beginning of the year until June 19, Israel was struck by 2,660 projectiles fired from Gaza. From June 19, when the tahdiya went into effect, to Nov. 4, the total was 65. But on Nov. 5 a new round of "negotiations" — with weapons — began when Israel struck what it said were militants tunneling under the Gaza fence. Hamas responded with a barrage of rocket fire that has continued for most of the past month," the Time report said.
A month earlier Yoram Cohen, until recently the Deputy Director of the Israeli intelligence service Shin Bet, wrote a similar account for the Washington Institute.
"Last week, Israeli forces entered Gaza, destroyed an underground border tunnel, and battled Hamas fighters, leaving several militants dead. In response, Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad fired around eighty rockets into southern Israel, including the Israeli city of Ashkelon," he wrote
"On June 19, 2008, Israel and Hamas began observing an Egyptian-mediated ceasefire, which was intended to last six months with an option to extend. In general, Hamas has observed the ceasefire; the number of attacks and rocket launches has decreased significantly, and Hamas has prevented other Gaza militant organizations from striking Israel," wrote Cohen.
Five weeks before the November 5 Israeli raid Secretary Rice was asked, because of Hamas' observance of the ceasefire whether a future administration might reach out to them. In an interview with Reuters at the Waldorf-Astoria in New York she was asked, "Okay. Hamas, whatever you may think of them, have more or less observed a ceasefire in Gaza in terms of rockets into Israel. Would you think that it might be for, perhaps, a future administration to try to, if only indirectly, reach out to them a bit more than has been possible up to now?"
Secretary Rice: "I think the proper course is reaching out to the Palestinian leadership, which by the way President Abbas, as President of the Palestinian Authority, is the legitimate president of all the Palestinian people and he is the negotiator as head of the PLO."
On the day of the Hamas announcement of its ending of the ceasefire on December 19 State Department spokesman Sean McCormack repeatedly acknowledged the effects of the ceasfire but couldn't quite bring himself to say it should be renewed.
At a daily press briefing in Washington McCormack was asked, "Do you have any reaction to the surge in tension in and around Gaza now that the truce has been broken?"
McCormack: "Well, as I said the other day, the interests of the people of the region, both Palestinians in Gaza as well as Israelis, are served by not having violence along that border. The people of Gaza have been ill-served by Hamas. They have – Hamas has only sought to create tensions and to try to derail efforts to arrive at a peaceful political solution between Israel and the Palestinians. And we would only hope that we see a continuation of the diminishment in levels of violence along that Gaza border.
Reporter: "And then you would like to see a restoration of the ceasefire?"
McCormack: "Well, this is something that was worked out involving the Israelis, involving the Palestinians, and I believe with the help of the Egyptians, and we weren’t involved in those efforts. I would only comment it from the perspective of you don’t want to see violence anywhere, because it’s only innocent people that are affected by it."
Reporter: "So, but I don’t get why, I mean, the Russians, for example, have said that they were not directly involved in establishing the ceasefire, but they have come out and said publicly they’d like to see it restored. And I wonder why you –"
McCormack: "Whatever the mechanism is, I mean, ultimately, what you want to see is a group like Hamas turn away from use of violence, abjure the use of violence, abjure terrorism. We’re not at that point yet. So that’s what we would like to see. Whatever the mechanism is that is acceptable to the Israeli Government to not see violence used against its citizens, then, of course, we’re not going to stand in the way of that. But – so I’m coming it at it from a little different perspective."
"You know, what we would like to see is Hamas be an organization that has completely turned away from terror. They haven’t done that. In the meantime, you have had these efforts at a truce, a hudna. And certainly, the fact that you haven’t had for some period of time violence along that border is a good thing for the people that – "
Reporter: "Well, I mean, one other thing. You said that Hamas has done nothing but seek to derail the efforts to achieve a political solution.
McCormack: "Mm-hmm."
Reporter: "But presumably, the fact that – and the levels of violence have indeed decreased under this ceasefire. I know they haven’t gone away. There have been rockets fired, but at a much lower rate than prior to the ceasefire. And I know that there have been Israeli actions, too. But again, less than previously. Presumably, the fact that Hamas chose, to some degree, to abjure from violence to some degree over this period was, in fact, something that created political space for the continuation of the negotiations that you’ve worked so hard on.
McCormack: "I don’t know. I guess – you know, again, the lack of violence along the borders in the interest of the people there, whether or not that has actually contributed to the ability of the Israeli Government and President Abbas to move forward the negotiating process, you would have to talk to both parties. I’m not equipped to make that political assessment of the situation in Israel as well as in the Palestinian areas."
"And what I was referring to is the fact that, you know, Hamas continues to try to rebuild its strength, that it continues to be an obstacle to a political settlement between the Israelis and the Palestinians, this diminution in the use of terror and violence notwithstanding."
President Bush in his radio address made it clear his administration was not interested in "another one-way ceasefire." It would appear the president would be in accord with Hamas on that point, hence the decision Islamic militant organization took not to renew.
As for Mr McCormack he probably unwittingly let the cat out of the bag: The U.S. was not interested in the ceasefire being renewed - notwithstanding it had been largely successful.
And Israel by virtue of the November 5 raid, and its retention of the blockade throughout the ceasefire, seemingly wasn't interested either.
Email this story to a friend
Comments on this story
| By all64, 01-03-09, 08:01 PM |
Blame BushAs much as I hate George Bush, to say that Hamas should be able to fire the missles without reprisal is ridiculous! Almost as ridiculous as the gutless dog who wrote this article without signing their name! Probably another communist wannabe. |
| By Barry Soetoro, 01-03-09, 07:04 PM |
MartyrsMay the martyrs get their 72 virgins. You know, the ones with horns and tails. |
| By Anonymous, 01-03-09, 07:09 PM |
"Paslestinian" rantingIt gets repeated ad naseum that the “por ole palestinians never done nothin bless their heart”. Only if “nothing” includes homicide attacks in buses and schools, crude home made rockets fired at Israeli cities hoping that somehow one will hit something and cause a civilian to die - preferably a child, holding the arabs in Gaza hostage because their deaths garners sympathy from the idiots world wide who either don’t know or don’t care what the issues are etc. et. etc.
The facts are that Israel has a legal, moral and ethical right to defend themselves and their soverign state. If the satan worshiping, death cult adherants of the false religion called Islam could get over their inferiority and learn to be human beings they could join the world as a recognized state.
Probably won’t happen...the descendants of Ishmael are indeed a wild ass of a man, their hand against every man and every man’s hand against them; constantly at war with their brothers. If they didn’t have Americans and Jews to hate that would simply continue to hate and murder other muslims. A pathetic excuse for humanity. |
| By Syed Suhail Khalid, 01-03-09, 04:28 PM |
Bush pig.George Bush the devil’s advocate,the devil’s shadow and the PRESIDENT PIG of USA has never spoken right and will never speak right.So what this Bush pig has said about Hamas is nothing new and unexpected.
Bush,you are going.And by God, you are the most hated person on earth forever.That is quite unlike the late President Saddam Hussain.Some drools may hate him,but he is very respected by a majority others.You know Bush,many parents have named and will name their children 'Saddam Hussain'.And these same families will name their pet dogs and street dogs GEORGE W BUSH jr.And then you know,even the dogs will start sulking for being named so. |
| By Anonymous, 01-03-09, 03:48 PM |
Hamas not to blame for current crisis despite Bush claimsWell this clown is only a few days away for ever also Rice so the words that come out of there Mouthe’s doenst matter this is the last fiasco he will made in international affairs.
The truth will come out sooner than later,and you will see what kind of people was running the US. |
| By Judea Victorious, 01-03-09, 09:09 PM |
Two suggestions for Israel(1) Get ALL the media out of Gaza - NOW, and (2) Start manufacturing a LOT of napalm. You cannot be forced to live in house where the next room is filled with scorpions that nobody else wants, and the only way you’re going to eradicate those scorpions is with something nasty and lasting. Napalm should do the trick. Fill the tunnels with the stuff. Send those Gazans packing. |
| By Bullshit, 01-03-09, 09:35 PM |
TrashOh the poor little Palestinians taking it from those big bully Israelis. Those little Arabs wouldn ever do anything to provoke such violence. All the Arabs do is show peace and love yet thos horrible Israelis just fire at them.
This is the biggest peice of biases trash journalism I have ever seen. The stinking rotten Arabs love to die and love to see their kids die..70 odd hairy arab virgins await them in “paradise”..go there the lot of you. You deserve it, you pick the fight then cry when the victim retaliates. The world will be better off without Arabs.
and by the way Mohammed was a paedophile |
| By sunday Reader, 01-03-09, 09:59 PM |
re: Bush PigTipical muslim no education just brain washes God Help Israel |
| By nachomama, 01-03-09, 10:11 PM |
| Beware Barack Hussein Obama. When he becomes President of the U.S., Israel is doomed. He is an Islamic Nazi. He wants to destroy Israel. You have been warned. |
| By don't have one, 01-03-09, 10:34 PM |
Do any of us have any idea.I can’t know for sure, but I don’t believe that any body posting here is in a position to say first hand what is actually going on from either side of the argument. I suspect people are basing their rhetoric on their own conditioning and prejudice depending on which side of the fence they have been exposed to. What is without question is that innocent citizens are being killed on both sides and in the case of Hamas, the innocent are being exposed by the actions of Hamas embedding themselves amongst the civilians as if to welcome the killing of their own people to further their cause and to gain the sympathy of the outside world. May peace prevail. |
| By Mohammad Al Naim, 01-04-09, 02:31 AM |
Hamas not to blame for current crisis despite Bush claims Does anybody know is the wall that displays all the Palestinians who have sacrificed themselves as suicide bombers? Has anyone interviewed the family of these suicide bombers? What is the living conditions of these families? I assure you no one has ever given a thought to the families. All they talk about are the Yasser Arafatâs of the world in the PLO, HAMAS and HEZBOLLAH. These people are not trying to build a better Palestine, just preach violence so they can be in power. Look at the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, the living conditions are deplorable. Where are the ARAB brothers? Where is the aid in the form of infrastructures? You donât see any of those from the wonderful ARAB brothers. If the Palestinian people have as a better living, it would be difficult for the terrorists to take hold. But that would mean doing something that makes sense and letting go of the dollar bills they are holding. Lip service is free and makes you look like you are doing something great when you are not. We always berate the west, it was the west that helped the Muslims in Yugoslavia. I donât remember any ARAB brothers doing their part or even providing any financial support to the US. So instead of being negative, the Palestinian brothers should work toward living in peace with your neighbors both Israel and Egypt. You are never ever going to get what is Israel. All the HAMAS rockets and suicide bombers are only going to get more Palestinians killed, I know Israelis are also being killed. But you have to ask yourself, who is hurting more the Palestinians or the Israelis. The answer is unanimously PALESTINIANS. So I plead to our PALESTINIAN brothers to opt for a PEACEFUL means to a better yourself instead of fighting for something that is unattainable like ISRAEL giving up its land. |
| By gogo, 01-04-09, 03:08 AM |
Woe is the worldWhere is world opionion when Hamas TARGETS civilian areas in Israel? But as soon as Israel RETALIATES everyone wakes up and calls for a stop..
They will NEVER defeat Israel nor will Jews not fight back. Nations of the world better wakeup because these terrorist animals will be on your soil if you dont support Israels right to retaliate. |
| By harry lavoe, 01-04-09, 03:09 AM |
border crossing attacksYou forget to mention the border crossings were constantly attacked when they were open. |
| By harry lavoe, 01-04-09, 04:51 AM |
think twice about sending rockets to israelsons of saladin and mamalukes bedouin arabs modern palestinians come from those people war like barbarians. They continue their ways the same as their grandfathers. Muslim world should not blame the west. They should blame the arab royals for trading israel for kingdoms.lol its in your arab blood to be a backstabber. The chosen ones will defeat arabs in all matters make love not war. Arabs will learn and submit to modern society and stop acting like apes. SO GET ON BOARD THE WEST TRAIN BEFORE IT LEAVES WITHOUT YOU AND YOUR FAMILIES AND THEY WILL DIE. Sons of saladin and mamalukes and bedouins have no right to jewish land. My american tax payer money is well spent on israel so I can worship freely where my religion is greater than islam. I flex my might. Bush cahooted with the royals to take over iraq and pump its oil. Bush with cat like reflexes could have beat the shitt out of that reporter. Bush can run the mile in six minutes. Bush can kick putins ass. Lol arabs you crack me up die and get your 72 virgins. What do the wives think about that. Their love must be rotten. Salaam dumb asses |
| By Adams08, 01-04-09, 03:51 PM |
adbasque@gmail.comWhat we see on the news and what’s really happening are two different things.
First we know that Hamas was created by Israel to serve that exact purpose to make sure, that peace will never take place.
I honestly don’t know why people are hoping for peace in that part of the world, it’s clear for over 60 years Israel does NOT want peace at all.
Even if the so called Hamas, stops attacking Israel, Israel will find another way to reinstate it’s occupation, They certainly don’t want a state of Palestine the Zionists want all of that land for them and kick the Palestinians out to the sea or to the other arab countries.
And for you Anonymous, 01-04-09
At least sammy used a name, why are you hiding behind anonymous?
Then from what I understand you agree with the genocide that is occuring in Palestine?
It was a holocaust when it was the jews, getting killed by the thousands, but not a holocaust when it’s muslims that are daying?
It doesn’t matter what they believe, what Israel is doing is inhuman, full stop.
|
| By Connosleeza, 01-04-09, 04:47 PM |
Is Condy Rice seeking an advocacy slot after stepping down?Condoleezza Rice, having observed that more than 300 Gazans were dead, said: “We are deeply concerned about the escalating violence. We strongly condemn the attacks on Israel and hold Hamas responsible."
Mark Steel, suggests that someone “should ask her to comment on teenage knife-crime, to see if she’d say: “I strongly condemn the people who’ve been stabbed, and until they abandon their practice of wandering around clutching their sides and bleeding, there is no hope for peace."
http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/mark-steel/mark-steel-so-what-have-the-palestinians-got-to-complain-about-1218135.html
According to Princeton Professor B. Chazelle: “Bombing Gaza is Israel’s version of “Yes We Can!" It’s electoral politics by other means. (There’s a big election in a month.)
If Lebanon '06 is any indication, this may end up badly. A ground invasion will be resisted at all costs by Israel (too dangerous), but, without it, rockets from Gaza are unlikely to be stopped.
So, then, what? The US is in no position to do anything: Condi no doubt sees birth pangs again, somewhere, and Bush is on his victory tour”
http://www.tinyrevolution.com/mt/archives/002745.html
|
| By Anonymous, 01-04-09, 02:58 AM |
Big PictureIf Hamas cared even one tiny little bit for the welfare of the Palestinian civilians they would have stopped firing rockets many days ago. They no doubt have a very pressing need to answer to their masters who have financed and supported their progress for so long.
The unfortunate Palestinian civilians are pawns in this war, they are paying with their lives and their children to satisfy the lust for power, control and revenge of those controlling the government of Israel and of those controlling Hamas.
This is an evil war; those responsible for the continual, opportunistic escalation of this conflict (including the author of this fine article) richly deserve to roast in hell for all of eternity.
No doubt Sharon is already paying the price, as will Bush, as will Meshaal. |
| By Anonymous, 01-03-09, 04:33 PM |
| May God bless all palastinans and May God rest all those martyrs in heaven.
|
| By E.G., 01-03-09, 05:29 PM |
Pray,, God, please have mercy on all of us! Give us guidance, peace and never leave us! God, Please save the innocents, punish the guilties and stop this war! Ameen!" |
| By ` ~galljdaj+, 01-03-09, 05:34 PM |
As a War Criminal, How could lil bush say differently??He, as well as the israelis, needs to claim 'innocent' for thier actions, therefore need to blame somebody else!
Sociopaths! it wasn’t me mama! honest to god! |
| By vitk, 01-03-09, 06:31 PM |
One-sided, indeed!So, the continued firing of rockets from Gaza into Israel during the “cease-fire”, the smuggling of rockets and other weaponry into Gaza, and the digging of a tunnel (or tunnels?) towards Israel were not violations??? |
| By ` ~galljdaj+, 01-03-09, 08:02 PM |
A Basic Tenent of 'self defense' is your ability to flee, i.e., AVOID THE HARM.When did israel ever 'avoid', Aggressor describes Israel.
Prep! And there is no defense claim possiple!
What evidence is there, of israel’s attempt at justice and equality from the signing of the UN Resolution 181, to Today? Rejection and violence has always been israel’s first endeavor, and only comes to the table of Justice when its feet are being burned.
Fron disembarking from the boats 'israel' has been the Aggressor. The abuser of Resolution 181, and never the facilitator. The Victims were 'ordained' with the disembarking and from the initial taking of Lands! |
| By Anonymous, 01-03-09, 08:07 PM |
| Go Israel, Get rid of the pagans, help them be so-called martyres. May the Lord be with you. |
| By Anonymous, 01-03-09, 08:10 PM |
| Scratch out the satanic verses and write in its place"JESUS ROCKS" |
| By JanetP, 01-04-09, 05:21 AM |
Gaza genocideI thought I was reading the Israeli Post. |
| By secretslave, 01-03-09, 10:52 PM |
Anti Wisdom in its foundational claim celebrated birth 1948salaam,
Makes Harry Truman of democracy anti Christ,
For Wisdom gave only one way upon OWNERSHIP values,
and they took NOT from Wisdom ,
as documented in the celebrated TREATY of its birth record and only implied one law,
as USA broke Wisdom not once but twice with ONE TREATY of support of a birth year 1948 |
| By secretslave, 01-03-09, 10:54 PM |
Breaking the laws given in Wisdom of ownership valuessalaam,
Bring them steps if you be of the TRUTHFUL,
as robbers do avoid courts of matters.
Description did not leave Wisdom of accuracy. |
| By secretslave, 01-03-09, 11:07 PM |
says it knows claims worthy of a court invitation?salaam = peace |
| By israeli pogi, 01-04-09, 12:32 AM |
Heaven get a new shipment of virgines.....But.......they are 80 years old....to bad Hamas....someone lie to you....HaHaHa |
| By Anonymous, 01-04-09, 12:39 AM |
| secretslave, I do not know how you have managed without a brain for so long, you must be Shaytan’s clone of himself, because you thrive on lies, idioticies and hot air, try to make this year for you the year that you may be regarded as a human being, or is this hoping for to much? |
| By Anonymous, 01-04-09, 07:10 AM |
| all64, are you talking about yourself again, I can’t see your name here either! Farhan ibn Yusuf |
| By Sammy, 01-04-09, 07:53 AM |
The cowards last stand before they will be judged by the International criminal court for crimes against humanityYes, after January 20th 2009, the international criminal court will begin rounding up all of those renegades that have broken international laws, and even thought and believed that they were excempt from having the international laws applied to them, because they were so fanatically brainwashed that they thought that they were on a killing mission for god.
But let us clear a few things, god does not sent people on a mission to kill, because god is love, and his love has no end, but he condems severely those that abuse, kill, and betray their fellow man by using his name as a justification to practice their evil, especially for obtaining economic gains at the expense of weak and unfortunate individuals who suffer, and suffer the consequences.
Sammy |
| By Anonymous, 01-04-09, 10:33 AM |
| sAMMY AND GALLJDAJ IS MEMBER OF THE MUSLIM RADICAL WHO WROTE ALL KIND OF BULLSHITS IN THE WEBSITE. BEWARE//////THEY ARE THE DEVIL IN DISGUISE.THERE IS NO VIRGIN WAITING FOR THEM IN HEAVEN |
Have your say on this story
|
|